Of the 21 caretaker managers given the permanent job in the Premier League era, the outcomes have been largely unsuccessful. Statistical analysis reveals that only four achieved a better points-per-game record in the long term than during their interim spell. Many, like Craig Shakespeare and Stuart Gray, were sacked quickly after appointment, while others saw significant drop-offs in form.
Notable exceptions include David O’Leary and Fulham’s Chris Coleman, though the most high-profile case is Ole Gunnar Solskjaer at Manchester United. Despite a blistering start, results significantly declined after his permanent deal was signed.
As Michael Carrick enjoys a positive spell as United’s current interim manager, history suggests that promoting from within is a risky gamble that rarely pays off.
Read More
